I am currently playing Tales of Xillia. It is a perfect example of everything that is wrong with the Japanese gaming industry. :/
As I've played the game, I've gone, "...why are all the women dressed like skanks?", "...they had to do the jiggle physics, eh?", "...KILL IT WITH FIRE," and "Wow, that character is the same as ____ from Tales of ____./ _____ is this game's _____ from that other Tales game."
The thing the game fails at and hits out of the park are from the same source: copying what came before. Where is gets it RIGHT is when it takes a gameplay element from other games - the leveling up system is straight out of FF13, and it's made it so you can interact more with the environment instead of invisible walls, including some short first-person elements, which is straight from western games. The leveling up system is a smoother, more streamlined version of the FF13 crystals, and they've improved how to get stores to have more items. They've also made it
fucking gorgeous.
Where it fails, however, is doing a copy-paste on the characters. This includes trying to include a "cute" character a ala a moogle or, even more fitting, Teddy from Persona 4. AND FAILING MISERABLY. Tipo is annoying as fuck, and I am not kidding, I have been yelling "Kill it with fire!" every single time it opens its mouth. It is that annoying. And also, for fuck's sake, game, you can not SERIOUSLY expect me to believe that a
fifteen year old is a last-year med school student and seeing patients. Unless his name is Dougie Howser, NO. The only way it'd make sense is if you set him up as some kinda genius, and y'all haven'T, and more than that, once the Child Character showed how, she took over being the healer. So. No. Likewise, it makes no sense for the main female character to be dressed in straps of leather and cloth, given the way the people dress where she is from, and especially when you handwave it with her saying, "A short skirt is comfortable to move in," which indicates that the person who wrote that line has never actually worn a skirt at all, let alone one that is skin-tight and barely covers your ass cheeks. They could have given her shorts that same length, and I'd have bought it, but a skirt, no. That's fanservice, and fuck you.
The story started out great and then the actually cookie-cutter characters showed up and I'm getting bored to tears with them, when I am not actively wishing for a flame thrower.
It's like the game devs haven't realized that a) the average gamer is no longer 15 and b) what was cool when they were 15 is not cool to someone in the age range of the average gamer, which is early-to-mid-30s. It's obvious that story and characterization were given a backseat, and it doesn't matter how good your game play mechanics are when you don't give a shit about the characters in an
RPG.
You can make a good game by taking previous elements from earlier titles and tweaking them.
You can not make a good story by taking characters from earlier titles and just changing their clothes and voices and dropping them into a story filled with similarly copy-pasted lines.
Tales of, I am disappoint.